How not to convince your reps
There are two ways to influence a politician: change the number of votes they’re receiving, and change the amount of money they’re receiving. For most of us, we can only really affect the first. In Dems to the Net: Go to hell, Lawrence Lessig complains about the Democrats appointing Hollywood Howard Berman to chair the House IP subcommittee, and tells Democrats he won’t be doing that either.
This is like making a congressman from Detroit head of a Automobile Safety sub-committee, or a senator from Texas head of a Global Warming sub-committee. Are you kidding, Dems? The choice signals clearly the party’s view about the issues, and its view of the “solution”: more of the same. This war—no more successful than President Bush’s war—will continue.
Here’s what any politician reading that saw:
blah blah i’ll continue to vote for Democrats no matter what blah blah blah
Lessig compares this year’s elections to Lucy holding the football for Charlie Brown. But he’s taking the part of Charlie Brown’s teachers: not saying anything anybody will hear; it has nothing to do with the show.
Copyright reform will probably end up going the way of medical marijuana: everyone “supports” it, but very few cast their votes based on that support. Rather than voting for someone based on that issue, they vote against other politicians based on other issues. The result is that there’s no need for politicians to support their issues. It won’t gain anybody any votes.
The only issues that matter are the issues you’re willing to change your vote for.
- Dems to the Net: Go to hell
- “‘Radical’ changes in Washington always have this Charlie Brown/Lucy-like character (remember Lucy holding the football?): it doesn’t take long before you realize how little really ever changes in DC. The latest example is the Dems and IP issues as they affect the Net. Message to the Net from the newly Democratic House? Go to hell.”
More Nobody For President
- Don’t wait—capitulate
- The ACLU’s doomed campaign against telecom immunity is a classic example of why you have to be willing to vote for Nobody if you want to be taken seriously in politics.
- Vote Nobody in 2008?
- Staying at home doesn’t send a message. Voting based on issues rather than party does.
- Term limits
- Term limit proposals avoid real problems. They’re a superficial solution at best. Efforts directed towards enacting term limits waste time and money that could be spent solving the underlying problems: a lack of new ideas and an ability to hide legislative bribery.
- Nobody wants immigration reform
- “Immigration is not a problem to be solved.” A confident and successful electorate could understand that issues are more important than who you hate. Unreasoning partisanship, however, is a problem that often seems as if it has no solution.
- Nobody Isn’t Partisan
- Partisanship always trumps principle, but this year is worse than any I can recall. If Nobody were on the ballot, he’d have a good chance of winning. With the election as close as any in recent years, Nobody might still garner a majority.
- Three more pages with the topic Nobody For President, and other related pages
More copyright
- Apple’s new Music Store ringtone policy
- I had started to consider purchasing digital downloads instead of CDs, but because download restrictions change too easily CDs remain a far better choice for me.
- Copyright and role-playing games
- Open source is especially important for computer code because copyright for computer code completely subverts the point of copyright.
- A writer’s will
- Neil Gaiman and Miss Snark encourage even unpublished writers to make known their desires with regard to their writings. Mine will be transferred to an open license within five years after I die.
- (Un)happy birthday, WKRP in Cincinnati!
- Under a reasonable copyright law, the rules of the game would not have been changed after play began. If we need longer copyright terms for future works, that’s one thing, but don’t break the contract with the public by extending copyright terms we’ve already paid for.
- Copyright for Filmmakers
- Keith Aoki, James Boyle, and Jennifer Jenkins have written a comic book about the impact of out-of-control copyright demands on documentaries.
- Eight more pages with the topic copyright, and other related pages
