It is widely believed that the news media is clueless
It looks like the media is settling on its narrative for Sarah Palin’s bestseller. Attack Palin? Too obvious. Besides, she fights back. Her book is a bestseller before it’s even out, and her Facebook posts affect White House policies: she now clearly has a voice to fight back with. Attack the co-author? The lawyers say that comes too close to libel. Attack someone the co-author worked with in the past? Not just guilt by association, but guilt by association by association? Ah, now, that’s cowardly enough for a journalist to use!
Listen to this from Meet the Press’s Rachel Maddow:
The person who’s writing her book… the last person who she co-authored a book with was called Donkey Cons, and it was co-authored with a guy who is wildly believed to be, and I believe him to be, a white supremacist. So she’s chosen Lynn Vincent, who’s written a book with a white supremacist to write her book.
Look at how “is believed to be” becomes “I believe” becomes unsupported fact—in a span of only two sentences. “Is believed to be” is one of the classic weasel phrases. It’s supposed to be heard as “I believe”, which is supposed to be heard as “true fact” without getting the speaker in trouble. But I don’t think I’ve ever seen the progression embodied in such an obvious manner before.
Now the Charleston Gazette has picked up on it, too. It’s hard to believe that this charge will stick. Even if the charge that Robert Stacy McCain were racist is true (and I see no evidence of it), Lynn Vincent is a writer. She works with all sorts of people. That noted racist Samuel L. Jackson may be starring in the movie adaption of a book about a “dangerous, homeless drifter”.
Guilt by association by association is becoming a standard attack against Palin. When Levi Johnston decides to pose for Playgirl, the headline doesn’t even mention his name. Instead, he’s billed as “father of Palin’s grandson”. If we’re all six degrees of separation from anyone else, soon the only name to appear in news reports will be Sarah Palin’s. I’d like dibs on “ Blogger who links to co-author of Sarah Palin’s co-author attacks media cluelessness.” Monique Stewart probably beat me to it, though.
She’ll be like Snowball in Animal Farm, her name a signifier that “this is bad”. Even President Obama will become “the ballot choice near Palin in the 2008 presidential election”. That could be a good thing: they’ll finally have a way to report on the administration’s missteps. “The administration of the ballot choice near Palin in the 2008 elections sided with a potential dictator in Honduras last month.” Or “The man whose vice president held televised discussions with Palin in 2008 betrayed pro-democracy activists in Iran during that country’s recent protests.”
Not even going to get into the not-so-subtle jab that she didn’t write the book. People with stories to tell team up with people who write for a living all the time. It’s what smart people do when they need to write a book and they’re not writers. Palin clearly has a compelling story, and she’s publicly crediting her co-author; that’s more than many other politicians do.
books
- DONKEY CONS: Sex, Crime & Corruption in the Democratic Party: Lynn Vincent and Robert Stacy McCain (hardcover)
- I have not yet read this book. But given the reaction it’s retroactively getting, I have Added It To The List.
- Going Rogue: An American Life: Sarah Palin (hardcover)
- When I heard that Palin was writing a book, I hoped it would be at least as much about her experiences in the campaign as a general autobiography. Sounds like that’s true. I’m looking forward to the Amazon preview.
- Same Kind of Different as Me: Ron Hall, Denver Moore, and Lynn Vincent (paperback)
- “A Modern-Day Slave, an International Art Dealer, and the Unlikely Woman Who Bound Them Together”
- Samuel L. Jackson will star in movie adaptation of Lynn Vincent’s book: Robert Stacy McCain at The Other McCain
- If you don’t read but would like to know more of Lynn Vincent’s work, you may be able to watch a movie with that widely-believed white supremacist, Samuel L. Jackson.
journalism
- Animal Farm
- Animal Farm is billed as “a provocative novel”, but that just underestimates our ability to be completely blind when faced with uncomfortable ideas.
- Fake journalists attacking real journalists: the smear campaign against Stacy McCain: Monique E. Stuart at HotMES
- “The new burden of proof, which apparently only requires that somebody believe the lie.”
- Jersey Democratic Party Shifts to Right
- Party lawyer Genova pulls Reagan defense, claims “I do not recall.”
- When I dreamed long ago of appearing some day on ‘Meet the Press’…: Robert Stacy McCain at The Other McCain
- “Rachel Maddow has got several facts wrong. She gets paid by MSNBC to report the facts, and as she goes about the process of proving she couldn’t find her own ass with both hands, I'll be content to watch and laugh.”
- ‘Retract, Please’: Letter to the Editor of the Charleston (W. Va.) Gazette: Robert Stacy McCain at The Other McCain
- “Having worked as a professional journalist since 1986, I have never forgotten the motto often repeated by those old-school editors who taught me the craft: If your mother says she loves you, check it out.”
More Sarah Palin
- Who is the fiscally-sane candidate?
- Which of the Republican candidates is most likely to help turn this country back on the path of fiscal sanity?
- Going Rogue: An American Life
- Unlike politicians who have to fall back on their ancestors for middle-class anecdotes, Palin lived them. In the seventies, her father took them from rural Idaho to greater opportunities in Alaska, but it wasn’t her father who built their family business: it was Todd and Sarah.
- Governor Perry and the role of government
- The Perry Gardasil flap is a very good example of the discussion needed for the role of government; the people trying to divert attention away from Perry’s decision and instead fight an army of strawmen are doing Republicans and independents a disservice.
- The endless campaign
- Should we have endless political campaigns? That’s the Barack Obama plan, but is it right for American politics?
- Sarah Palin’s Gordian Knot: Slicing crony capitalism
- “Real hope isn’t in an individual. It’s not in a politician, certainly… don’t wait for the permanent political class to reform anything for you. They won’t. They can’t. They can’t even take responsibility for their own actions.”
- 15 more pages with the topic Sarah Palin, and other related pages
