Driving laws too complicated for DMV
We’ve known for a long time that our tax laws are so complicated that even the IRS can’t reliably advise you about them. That’s not the only place where we can’t know if we’re following the law. Its become a truism that motor vehicle laws are so complicated that nobody can follow them: that any police officer worth their training can cite anybody in order to justify a stop after the event.
Now it turns out that we can’t even trust the Department of Motor Vehicles.
The Republican governor’s lack of a motorcycle endorsement--or an M-1 or M-2 designation--on his license came to light on Monday, a day after the motorcycle he was operating with a sidecar collided with a neighbor’s car. On Tuesday, Los Angeles police and state officials were at odds about whether Schwarzenegger illegally operated that motorcycle.
California Highway Patrol spokesman Tom Marshall and Department of Motor Vehicles spokesman Mike Miller said the law is different for motorcycles with sidecars attached. They said the Class C license Schwarzenegger holds is enough to legally drive that type of motorcycle, and the DMV motorcycle handbook backs them up.
But a spokesman for the Los Angeles Police Department, which investigated the accident, said the governor needed a motorcycle endorsement to legally operate the motorcycle - even if it did have a sidecar attached.
Lt. Paul Vernon cited the vehicle code, which includes a motorcycle with a sidecar under the definition of what is a motorcycle.
When the law becomes so complicated that even those charged with enforcement--in this case, the DMV and the Highway Patrol--can’t get it right, how can the rest of us be expected to comply with it? The law becomes little more than a tool used to harass whoever an agent of the state charged with enforcing it wants to harass.
- Governor ‘never thought’ to get license
- “The CHP and L.A. police disagree about the rules for motorcycle permits.”
More reigning in bad laws
- A customer service model of federal spending
- “If we can put a moon on the man, why cannot we devise a system whereby every state is billed by DC annually, and let the states compete for citizens to pay the taxes?” Moving from a system where the federal government taxes individuals to one where the federal government taxes state governments makes all of our lives a lot simpler and solves a lot of thorny civil rights issues as well.
- Wachovia fines encourage drug trafficking
- Some people are wondering why no one at Wachovia went to jail for money laundering. The authorities received 160 million dollars in forfeiture and fines. Why would they want to discourage future banks from acting as Wachovia did?
- Don’t mess with the deck chairs, fix the boat!
- Advice for the incoming House. Make them deny it! And don’t try to fool us by changing the deck chairs.
- Justice conjured is justice denied
- Blunting criticism of bad laws by exempting nice people.
- Has welfare failed us?
- Has welfare failed us, or have we overwhelmed the welfare system through other policies that encourage dependance and discourage economic development?
- 13 more pages with the topic reigning in bad laws, and other related pages
More traffic laws
- Bad laws cause crime
- “Honestly, the level of apathy I’m dealing with is maddening.” Bad laws make it easy to get away with breaking them.
- Speeding and budgets: Conflict of Interest
- Obviously, the money generated by speed laws creates a conflict of interest for state lawmakers, who will need more “lawbreakers” in order to meet budget numbers. But the conflict of interest doesn’t always stop there.
- Targeting critics of the law
- When Canadian journalist Kerry Diotte criticized red light cameras in Edmonton, Edmonton police started looking for a reason to arrest him.
- Massachusetts State Police encourage speeding
- Massachusetts State Police have made it clear that speeding laws are not about safety, but only revenue.
- At least I got to see the officer squirm
- Traffic court has a very high opinion of humans’ ability to violate the laws of physics.
- Two more pages with the topic traffic laws, and other related pages
More California
- California threatens Amazon, kills affiliate programs
- By this time, California had to know that its new law would not bring in new tax revenue. The tax headaches aren’t worth the trouble of maintaining affiliate programs. The only reason to pass the law was to kill affiliate programs at places like Amazon and Overstock. I don’t understand; what is it about affiliate programs that states don’t like?
- Tax event horizon
- How close are we to a tax event horizon, where so many people’s income depends on complicated tax laws?
- Sometimes you wonder, other times you expunge the vote
- California state assembly so proud of vote they… erase it from the public record.
- California eminent domain reform: 98 or 99?
- Thanks to Ilya Somin on the Volokh Conspiracy for explaining why proposition 98 is the one that needs supporting.
- Orwellian proposition 91
- When a bureaucracy makes rules about what constitutes a “for” or “against” argument, it’s inevitable that common sense will take a back seat to the rules
- Eight more pages with the topic California, and other related pages
